On my main server of Staghelm, Dominos seems to work just fine, even if I create a new character. But if I make new characters on another server, Dominos doesn't replace the default bar. Instead if just puts Dominos bars over what is already there.

I have turned off Dominos and then back on and even completely deleted out the addon folders of Dominos and re-downloaded and re-installed. It still is just putting a layover instead of replacement.

Is there a setting somewhere that I am missing?

Have you confirmed that the problem happens with just Dominos enabled? I suspect that the new character may have an addon enabled that your main does not.

Ah! Thank you so much!!! I had an old addon that I didn't like but hadn't deleted yet that was being turned on when I made toons on other servers. Woot! :D I appreciate it!!!