Hello,

so yeah basically i kill a rare and it stays on the map :p

https://imgur.com/fUxWU0A

https://imgur.com/TkgF9tM

here are 2 examples of me killing them both (green name) and staying on my map regardless, so i'm wondering if it's a bug in the "progress" check on load of the addon or some other issue ?

If you came back later, this is because all rares are dailies this expansion. So the skull on your map is appearing if it's present-and-killable-for-loot.

I've been meaning to add a preference to make the achievement authoritative.

There's now a preference for making achievement-complete the only thing that counts.

Could I persuade you to type the following into your chat and let me know what it prints out?

/dump C_QuestLog.IsQuestFlaggedCompleted(57705)
/dump C_QuestLog.IsQuestFlaggedCompleted(57708)

Also, what faction are you?

both values came out as 'False'

and i'm alliance on those chars from the screenshots

Did they disappear when you killed them and come back later, or did they just never disappear?

i do "think" they went away in my very first playthrough but ofc i was not paying massive attention on that when leveling :p

is there some other way to test that could help you out ?