Hekili Priority Helper

Hekili Priority Helper

44M Downloads

Paladin / Protection - Blessing of Dawn and Dusk priority

GHSTSHP opened this issue ยท 4 comments

commented

Before You Begin

  • I confirm that I have downloaded the latest version of the addon.
  • I am not playing on a private server.
  • I checked for an existing, open ticket for this issue and was not able to find one.
  • I edited the title of this issue (above) so that it describes the issue I am reporting.
  • I am reporting an issue with the default priority included with the specialization (imported or edited priorities are not supported).

Describe the Issue

I'm curious if it's possible to add blessing of dawn and dusk to the simc priority. Admittedly, I am not smart enough to edit that data in any meaningful or accurate way.

Thank you!

How to Reproduce

I don't see the spell in the priority list and the default priority never seems to want me to bank five holy power.

Snapshot (Link)

Protection Paladin; Interrupts - N/A build: v10.0.5-1.0.20 level: 70 (70) class: PALADIN spec: protection talents: ardent_defender = 1/1 aspiration_of_divinity = 2/2 auras_of_the_resolute = 1/1 avengers_shield = 1/1 avenging_wrath = 1/1 avenging_wrath_might = 1/1 bastion_of_light = 1/1 blessed_hammer = 1/1 blessing_of_freedom = 1/1 blessing_of_protection = 1/1 blessing_of_sacrifice = 1/1 bulwark_of_order = 2/2 bulwark_of_righteous_fury = 1/1 cavalier = 1/1 consecration_in_flame = 1/1 crusaders_judgment = 1/1 crusaders_resolve = 1/1 divine_resonance = 1/1 divine_steed = 1/1 divine_toll = 1/1 eye_of_tyr = 1/1 ferren_marcuss_fervor = 2/2 fist_of_justice = 2/2 golden_path = 1/1 grand_crusader = 1/1 greater_judgment = 1/1 guardian_of_ancient_kings = 1/1 hallowed_ground = 1/1 hammer_of_wrath = 1/1 holy_aegis = 2/2 holy_shield = 1/1 incandescence = 1/1 judgment_of_light = 1/1 lay_on_hands = 1/1 moment_of_glory = 1/1 of_dusk_and_dawn = 1/1 rebuke = 1/1 redoubt = 1/1 relentless_inquisitor = 1/1 righteous_protector = 2/2 sacrifice_of_the_just = 1/1 sanctified_wrath = 1/1 seal_of_might = 2/2 seal_of_order = 1/1 seal_of_reprisal = 1/2 seal_of_the_crusader = 2/2 seasoned_warhorse = 1/1 shining_light = 1/1 soaring_shield = 1/1 strength_of_conviction = 2/2 tyrs_enforcer = 2/2 unbreakable_spirit = 1/1 zealots_paragon = 1/1 pvptalents: none covenant: none conduits: none soulbinds: [] sets: decoration_of_flame = 1 tier29 = 4 gear: alacritous_alchemist_stone = 1 broodsworn_legionnaires_pavise = 1 decoration_of_flame = 1 elemental_lariat = 1 frostfire_legguards_of_preparation = 1 goldsteel_bindings = 1 illusion_breakers_waistguard = 1 seal_of_filial_duty = 1 shield = 1 signet_of_titanic_insight = 1 strike_twice = 1 tabard_of_the_lightbringer = 1 tier29 = 4 undisputed_champions_shirt = 1 valkyra_protector_greatboots = 1 vibrant_wildercloth_shawl = 1 virtuous_silver_breastplate = 1 virtuous_silver_gauntlets = 1 virtuous_silver_heaume = 1 virtuous_silver_pauldrons = 1 legendaries: none itemIDs: 109878, 136772, 190523, 191492, 192999, 193001, 193511, 193650, 193700, 194299, 195520, 195526, 200414, 200416, 200417, 200419, 52252, 98082 settings: aoe = 2 buffPadding = 0 combatRefresh = 0.1 custom1Name = Custom 1 custom2Name = Custom 2 cycle = false cycle_min = 6 damage = true damageDots = false damageExpiration = 8 damageOnScreen = true damagePets = false damageRange = 0 debuffPadding = 0 enabled = true enhancedRecheck = false gcdSync = true maxTime = 10 nameplateRange = 8 nameplates = true noFeignedCooldown = false package = Protection Paladin petbased = false potion = phantom_fire regularRefresh = 0.5 throttleRefresh = false throttleTime = false ds_damage = 100 goak_damage = 50 wog_health = 0 toggles: cooldowns = true custom1 = false custom2 = false defensives = false essences = true [overridden] interrupts = true [separate] mode = automatic potions = false keybinds: ardent_defender = N3 [01] avengers_shield = R [05] avenging_wrath = N1 [05] bastion_of_light = N4 [05] blessed_hammer = T [05] blessing_of_freedom = N5 [06] blessing_of_protection = N+ [01] blessing_of_sacrifice = N8 [06] cleanse_toxins = 6 [06] consecration = Q [05] decoration_of_flame = S [03] divine_shield = N0 [05] divine_steed = N2 [06] divine_toll = 9 [06] eye_of_tyr = 8 [06] flash_of_light = 1 [01] guardian_of_ancient_kings = N6 [01] hammer_of_justice = 7 [06] hammer_of_wrath = E [05] hand_of_reckoning = A [03] healthstone = 2 [01] intercession = N- [06] judgment = W [05] lay_on_hands = N7 [05] moment_of_glory = N9 [01] rebuke = 0 [06] shield_of_the_righteous = F [03] will_to_survive = 5 [01] word_of_glory = D [03] warnings: [#1] Auditor removed an aura 383843 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193385-000002BA2E after exiting combat. [#2] Auditor removed an aura 31935 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193385-000002BA2E after exiting combat. [#3] Auditor removed an aura 385723 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193385-000002BA2E after exiting combat. [#4] Auditor removed an aura 196941 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193385-000002BA2E after exiting combat. [#5] Auditor removed an aura 197277 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193385-000002BA2E after exiting combat. [#6] Auditor removed an aura 383843 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193145-000002BD30 after exiting combat. [#7] Auditor removed an aura 31935 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193145-000002BD30 after exiting combat. [#8] Auditor removed an aura 196941 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193145-000002BD30 after exiting combat. [#9] Auditor removed an aura 197277 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193145-000002BD30 after exiting combat. [#10] Auditor removed an aura 383843 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193394-000002BAED after exiting combat. [#11] Auditor removed an aura 31935 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-193394-000002BAED after exiting combat. [#12] Auditor removed an aura 383843 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000082BDEC after exiting combat. [#13] Auditor removed an aura 383843 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000002BDEC after exiting combat. [#14] Auditor removed an aura 385723 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000002BDEC after exiting combat. [#15] Auditor removed an aura 204301 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000082BDEC after exiting combat. [#16] Auditor removed an aura 204301 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000002BDEC after exiting combat. [#17] Auditor removed an aura 196941 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000002BDEC after exiting combat. [#18] Auditor removed an aura 197277 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000002BDEC after exiting combat. [#19] Auditor removed an aura 204242 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-191553-000282BBE6 after exiting combat. [#20] Auditor removed an aura 204242 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000082BDEC after exiting combat. [#21] Auditor removed an aura 204242 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194570-000002BDEC after exiting combat. [#22] Auditor removed an aura 383843 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-191553-000102BBE6 after exiting combat. [#23] Auditor removed an aura 196941 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-191553-000102BBE6 after exiting combat. [#24] Auditor removed an aura 197277 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-191553-000102BBE6 after exiting combat. [#25] Auditor removed an aura 383843 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194624-000002BDFC after exiting combat. [#26] Auditor removed an aura 196941 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194624-000002BDFC after exiting combat. [#27] Auditor removed an aura 197277 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-194624-000002BDFC after exiting combat. [#28] Auditor removed an aura 204242 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195712-000002413A after exiting combat. [#29] Auditor removed an aura 204242 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195712-00000240E7 after exiting combat. [#30] Auditor removed an aura 196941 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195712-00000240E7 after exiting combat. [#31] Auditor removed an aura 196941 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195712-000002413A after exiting combat. [#32] Auditor removed an aura 197277 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195712-00000240E7 after exiting combat. [#33] Auditor removed an aura 197277 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195712-000002413A after exiting combat. [#34] Auditor removed an aura 204301 from Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195712-000002413A after exiting combat. targets: nameplate2 - 0 - Creature-0-4232-2444-2632-195762-000002C418 - 300.00 - 0 - Mossy Gulper player_buffs: 465 - devotion_aura - 1 - 3600.00 368901 - *cliffside_wylderdrake - 1 - 3600.00 383169 - *lucky_horseshoe - 1 - 3600.00 186406 - *sign_of_the_critter - 1 - 3600.00 384235 - *vantus_rune_broodkeeper_diurna - 1 - 297685.53 225788 - *sign_of_the_emissary - 1 - 3600.00 386984 - *wind_friend - 1 - 1640.66 297871 - *anglers_water_striders - 1 - 3600.00 player_debuffs: target_auras: target does not exist New Recommendations for [ Interrupts ] requested at 22:18:33 ( 685575.99 ); using built-in ( Protection Paladin ) priority. *** START OF NEW DISPLAY: Interrupts *** RECOMMENDATION #1 ( Offset: 0.00, GCD: 0.00, Casting: 0.00 ). Resources: holy_power[ 0.00 / 5.00 ], mana[ 50000.00 / 50000.00 ] Checking if I'm casting ( No ) and if it is a channel ( No ). No whitelist. Processing precombat action list [ Protection Paladin - precombat ]. Current recommendation was NO ACTION at +10.00s. 1. devotion_aura ( precombat - 1 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.05ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-precombat-1:devotion_aura:0.05:Ability Known, Enabled(0.05) 2. lights_judgment ( precombat - 2 ) - ability unknown Time spent on this action: 0.30ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-precombat-2:lights_judgment:0.30:Ability Known, Enabled(0.30) 3. arcane_torrent ( precombat - 3 ) - ability unknown Time spent on this action: 0.07ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-precombat-3:arcane_torrent:0.07:Ability Known, Enabled(0.07) 4. consecration ( precombat - 4 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-precombat-4:consecration:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) Exiting precombat with recommendation of NO ACTION at +10.00s. Completed precombat action list [ Protection Paladin - precombat ]. Processing default action list [ Protection Paladin - default ]. Current recommendation was NO ACTION at +10.00s. 5. rebuke ( default - 1 ) The action is not ready ( 3600.00 ) before our maximum delay window ( 10.00 ) for this query. Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-default-1:rebuke:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 6. cleanse_toxins ( default - 2 ) - talent [ cleanse_toxins ] missing Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-default-2:cleanse_toxins:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 7. call_action_list:cooldowns ( default - 3 ) There is no criteria for cooldowns. Action list (cooldowns) was found. + cooldowns Current recommendation was NO ACTION at +10.00s. 8. seraphim ( cooldowns - 1 ) - talent [ seraphim ] missing Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-cooldowns-1:seraphim:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 9. avenging_wrath ( cooldowns - 2 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.07ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-cooldowns-2:avenging_wrath:0.07:Ability Known, Enabled(0.07) 10. avenging_wrath ( cooldowns - 3 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.07ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-cooldowns-3:avenging_wrath:0.07:Ability Known, Enabled(0.07) 11. potion ( cooldowns - 4 ) - ability disabled ( toggle a ) Time spent on this action: 0.66ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-cooldowns-4:potion:0.66:Ability Known, Enabled(0.66) 12. moment_of_glory ( cooldowns - 5 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.07ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-cooldowns-5:moment_of_glory:0.07:Ability Known, Enabled(0.07) 13. holy_avenger ( cooldowns - 6 ) - talent [ holy_avenger ] missing Time spent on this action: 0.06ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-cooldowns-6:holy_avenger:0.06:Ability Known, Enabled(0.06) 14. bastion_of_light ( cooldowns - 7 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.07ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-cooldowns-7:bastion_of_light:0.07:Ability Known, Enabled(0.07) Exiting cooldowns with recommendation of NO ACTION at +10.00s. Returned from list (cooldowns), current recommendation is NO ACTION (+10.00). - cooldowns 15. call_action_list:mitigation ( default - 4 ) There is no criteria for mitigation. Action list (mitigation) was found. + mitigation Current recommendation was NO ACTION at +10.00s. 16. shield_of_the_righteous ( mitigation - 1 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-mitigation-1:shield_of_the_righteous:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 17. word_of_glory ( mitigation - 2 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-mitigation-2:word_of_glory:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 18. guardian_of_ancient_kings ( mitigation - 3 ) - ability disabled ( toggle a ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-mitigation-3:guardian_of_ancient_kings:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 19. divine_shield ( mitigation - 4 ) - ability disabled ( toggle a ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-mitigation-4:divine_shield:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 20. ardent_defender ( mitigation - 5 ) - ability disabled ( toggle a ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-mitigation-5:ardent_defender:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 21. lay_on_hands ( mitigation - 6 ) - ability disabled ( toggle a ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-mitigation-6:lay_on_hands:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) Exiting mitigation with recommendation of NO ACTION at +10.00s. Returned from list (mitigation), current recommendation is NO ACTION (+10.00). - mitigation 22. call_action_list:trinkets ( default - 5 ) There is no criteria for trinkets. Action list (trinkets) was found. + trinkets Current recommendation was NO ACTION at +10.00s. 23. variable ( trinkets - 1 ) - variable.trinket_1_sync will check this script entry ( Protection Paladin:trinkets:1 ) 1 Time spent on this action: 0.04ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-1:variable:0.04:Ability Known, Enabled(0.02):Post-TTR and Essential(0.02) 24. variable ( trinkets - 2 ) - variable.trinket_2_sync will check this script entry ( Protection Paladin:trinkets:2 ) 1 Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-2:variable:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.02):Post-TTR and Essential(0.01) 25. variable ( trinkets - 3 ) - variable.trinket_priority will check this script entry ( Protection Paladin:trinkets:3 ) 2 Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-3:variable:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.02):Post-TTR and Essential(0.01) 26. variable ( trinkets - 4 ) - variable.trinket_1_buffs will check this script entry ( Protection Paladin:trinkets:4 ) trinket.t1.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t1.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t1.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t1.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t1.has_use_buff[false] Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-4:variable:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.02):Post-TTR and Essential(0.01) 27. variable ( trinkets - 5 ) - variable.trinket_2_buffs will check this script entry ( Protection Paladin:trinkets:5 ) trinket.t2.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t2.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t2.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t2.has_use_buff[false] | trinket.t2.has_use_buff[false] Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-5:variable:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.02):Post-TTR and Essential(0.01) Bypassing 'trinket1' action because the equipped trinket #1 is not usable. 28. trinket1 ( trinkets - 6 ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-6:trinket1:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) Substituting decoration_of_flame for Trinket #2 action; it is otherwise not included in the priority. 29. decoration_of_flame ( trinkets - 7 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.31ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-7:decoration_of_flame:0.31:Ability Known, Enabled(0.31) Bypassing 'trinket1' action because the equipped trinket #1 is not usable. 30. trinket1 ( trinkets - 8 ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-8:trinket1:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) Substituting decoration_of_flame for Trinket #2 action; it is otherwise not included in the priority. 31. decoration_of_flame ( trinkets - 9 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.28ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-trinkets-9:decoration_of_flame:0.28:Ability Known, Enabled(0.28) 32. use_items ( trinkets - 10 ) There is no criteria for Use Items. + trinkets, items Current recommendation was NO ACTION at +10.00s. Exiting items with recommendation of NO ACTION at +10.00s. Returned from Use Items; current recommendation is NO ACTION (+10.00). - items Exiting trinkets with recommendation of NO ACTION at +10.00s. Returned from list (trinkets), current recommendation is NO ACTION (+10.00). - trinkets 33. call_action_list:standard ( default - 6 ) There is no criteria for standard. Action list (standard) was found. + standard Current recommendation was NO ACTION at +10.00s. 34. shield_of_the_righteous ( standard - 1 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-1:shield_of_the_righteous:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 35. shield_of_the_righteous ( standard - 2 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-2:shield_of_the_righteous:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 36. avengers_shield ( standard - 3 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-3:avengers_shield:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 37. hammer_of_wrath ( standard - 4 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-4:hammer_of_wrath:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 38. judgment ( standard - 5 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-5:judgment:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 39. divine_toll ( standard - 6 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.07ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-6:divine_toll:0.07:Ability Known, Enabled(0.07) 40. avengers_shield ( standard - 7 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-7:avengers_shield:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 41. hammer_of_wrath ( standard - 8 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-8:hammer_of_wrath:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 42. judgment ( standard - 9 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-9:judgment:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 43. consecration ( standard - 10 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-10:consecration:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 44. eye_of_tyr ( standard - 11 ) - ability disabled ( toggle a ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-11:eye_of_tyr:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 45. blessed_hammer ( standard - 12 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-12:blessed_hammer:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 46. hammer_of_the_righteous ( standard - 13 ) - talent [ hammer_of_the_righteous ] missing Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-13:hammer_of_the_righteous:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 47. crusader_strike ( standard - 14 ) - talent [ blessed_hammer ] disallowed Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-14:crusader_strike:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 48. word_of_glory ( standard - 15 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-15:word_of_glory:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) 49. consecration ( standard - 16 ) - ability disabled ( display ) Time spent on this action: 0.03ms TimeData:Protection Paladin-standard-16:consecration:0.03:Ability Known, Enabled(0.03) Exiting standard with recommendation of NO ACTION at +10.00s. Returned from list (standard), current recommendation is NO ACTION (+10.00). - standard Exiting default with recommendation of NO ACTION at +10.00s. Completed default action list [ Protection Paladin - default ]. Recommendation is NO ACTION at 0.00 + 10.00. Recommendation #1 is NO ACTION at 10.00s (10.00s). Resources: Resources: holy_power[ 0.00 / 5.00 | 0.00 @ [1 - actual] 0.00 ], mana[ 50000.00 / 50000.00 | 50000.00 @ [1 - actual] 0.00 ] Time spent generating recommendations: 4.50ms

Raidbots Sim Report (Link)

No response

Additional Information

No response

Contact Information

No response

commented

For the sake of time, I'll go ahead and make adjustments based on my own assumptions and we'll see how it goes.

commented

Here's a snapshot where Hekili is recommending SotR when I have 3 HoPo, blessing of the dusk is active, and blessing of the dawn is not active. https://pastebin.com/FJSyXQPj

And here's a quick sim of my character: https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/tcqCAS4hwy9C1L4ffKopXj

Hope they help!

commented

In the last few days I have also noticed that following Hekili recommendations no longer triggers Blessing of Dawn. It maintains Blessing of Dusk, but it won't build to 5 holy power.

commented

Thanks for adding to the thread. Could you post a snapshot to Pastebin where a HoPo spender is recommended without reaching 5 HoPo when playing as Protection. I'm assuming this is the recent priority update that uses SotR more, but I'd like confirmation before I turn that logic off if ODTD is not talented.