Before You Begin

• I confirm that I have downloaded the latest version of the addon.
• I am not playing on a private server.
• I checked for an existing, open ticket for this issue and was not able to find one.
• I edited the title of this issue (above) so that it describes the issue I am reporting.
• I am reporting an issue with the default priority included with the specialization (imported or edited priorities are not supported).

Spec

DH - Havoc

Describe the Issue

After today's update, Havoc opener improved but it's not working properly yet. During prepull, immolation aura gets recommended after sigil of flame and felblade gets recommended before The Hunt until we enter combat. Finally, after the first vengeful Retreat the recommendation is a chaos strike, and not Metamorphosis as it should be

How to Reproduce

1. Play as Havoc on an ST dummy
2. execute the rotation by using FS raid build

Snapshot (Link)

prepull: https://pastebin.com/NheXM1uM felblade rec: https://pastebin.com/aYYqvacj Vengeful Retreat section: https://pastebin.com/7WtK8Ar6 https://pastebin.com/SN2eYDQn

Raidbots Sim Report (Link)

https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/fsJmDtE2WYmVMbs89cGZTJ

Additional Information

No response

Contact Information

yokaii__

NOTE: there's also another issue after the first Death Sweep where, before using vengeful retreat and meta, we must cast a Chaos Strike to not waste a Demonsurge, you can also notice that the proc is up. Snapshot: https://pastebin.com/L32CK4u8

NOTE 2: I have also noticed that the addon struggles to manage the Fury and at some point, it forgets to recommend abilities like chaos blades, immolation aura, or sigil of flame even when they are off cd https://pastebin.com/TfDRWviq

EDIT: another situation where I was struggling on Fury and the recommendations got stuck https://pastebin.com/P3LuSRqn https://pastebin.com/LUcTnZgY

NOTE 3: For this one I can't catch a snapshot for now because it's hard to reproduce, however sometimes the addon recommends vengeful retreat when Eye Beam is almost ready, making us lose the initiative proc. Secondly, it happened once that instead of waiting Essence Break to be off cd (2-3s left) the addon recommended using death sweep making us lose another dps proc

EDIT: not the same thing, but the addon failed to pair vengeful retreat with meta here by recommending retreat randomly when meta was coming back in 8s https://pastebin.com/XN31VuKi

NOTE 4: Sometimes even if both EB and Death Sweep are up, the addon recommends to cast DS before EB. Also, there are still some issues sometimes where immo aura, sigil and blade dance don't get recommended even if they are off cd

During prepull, immolation aura gets recommended after sigil of flame

Yes.

and felblade gets recommended before The Hunt until we enter combat.

Yes.

The conditions for this Felblade in the opener action list are:

felblade,if=(buff.metamorphosis.down|fury<40)&(!talent.a_fire_inside|hero_tree.aldrachi_reaver)&action.felblade.cooldown_react

I'll bold the portions where criteria are met in your snapshot for the ability to be recommended.

• this entry's criteria PASSES: ( buff.metamorphosis.down[true] | fury.current[55.00] < 40 ) & ( ! talent.a_fire_inside.enabled[false] | hero_tree.aldrachi_reaver[false] ) & action.felblade.cooldown_react[true]`

Both the sim and the addon are using the same criteria; you can see that this entry would disappear if both Metamorphosis were active and your Fury reaches 40+. If Felblade vanishes under other circumstances, please provide a snapshot that shows this.

Finally, after the first vengeful Retreat the recommendation is a chaos strike, and not Metamorphosis as it should be

Here, we have a discrepancy to look at:

vengeful_retreat,use_off_gcd=1,if=(prev_gcd.1.death_sweep&buff.initiative.remains<2&buff.inner_demon.down|buff.initiative.remains<0.5&debuff.initiative_tracker.up&(!talent.inertia|buff.unbound_chaos.down))&((!talent.essence_break&talent.shattered_destiny)|(talent.essence_break&!talent.shattered_destiny)|(!talent.shattered_destiny&!talent.essence_break))|prev_gcd.2.death_sweep&prev_gcd.1.annihilation

• this entry's criteria PASSES: ( prev_gcd[1].death_sweep[true] & buff.initiative.remains[0.00] < 2 & buff.inner_demon.down[false] | buff.initiative.remains[0.00] < 0.5 & debuff.initiative_tracker.up[true] & ( ! talent.inertia.enabled[true] | buff.unbound_chaos.down[true] ) ) & ( ( ! talent.essence_break.enabled[true] & talent.shattered_destiny.enabled[false] ) | ( talent.essence_break.enabled[true] & ! talent.shattered_destiny.enabled[false] ) | ( ! talent.shattered_destiny.enabled[false] & ! talent.essence_break.enabled[true] ) ) | prev_gcd[2].death_sweep[false] & prev_gcd[1].annihilation[false]

It's possible that debuff.initiative_tracker.up is wrong, in which case this entry wouldn't show yet; this entry would then show after Annihilatebecauseprev_gcd[2].death_sweep & prev_gcd[1].annihilation` will flip to true. I'll look into it.

NOTE: there's also another issue after the first Death Sweep where, before using vengeful retreat and meta, we must cast a Chaos Strike to not waste a Demonsurge, you can also notice that the proc is up. Snapshot: pastebin.com/L32CK4u8

This is the same as previous. The Vengeful Retreat criteria are met, but the Annihilation entry has to happen before Metamorphosis' criteria are met (to avoid wasting the Demonsurge: Annihilation):

metamorphosis,if=...

• this entry's criteria FAILS: ( ( ! talent.initiative.enabled[true] | cooldown.vengeful_retreat.remains[20.00] ) & cooldown.blade_dance.remains[5.03] & ( ( cooldown.death_sweep.remains[5.03] | buff.metamorphosis.up[true] & buff.metamorphosis.remains[2.53] < ( gcd.max[1.00] * 1.5 ) ) & cooldown.eye_beam.remains[35.90] & ( ! talent.essence_break.enabled[true] | debuff.essence_break.up[false] | cooldown.essence_break.true_remains[0.00] > cooldown.essence_break.duration[40.00] - debuff.essence_break.duration[4.00] | talent.shattered_destiny.enabled[false] | hero_tree.felscarred[true] ) & buff.fel_barrage.down[true] & ( raid_event.adds['in'][3600.00] > 40 | ( raid_event.adds.remains[0.00] > 8 | ! talent.fel_barrage.enabled[false] ) & active_enemies[1.00] > 2 ) | ! talent.chaotic_transformation.enabled[true] | fight_remains[98.32] < 30 ) & ( buff.inner_demon.down[false] & ( buff.rending_strike.down[true] | ! talent.restless_hunter.enabled[false] | prev_gcd[1].death_sweep[true] ) ) ) & ( talent.inertia.enabled[true] | talent.essence_break.enabled[true] ) & ( hero_tree.aldrachi_reaver[false] | ( buff.demonsurge_death_sweep.down[true] | buff.metamorphosis.remains[2.53] < gcd.max[1.00] ) & ( buff.demonsurge_annihilation.down[false] ) ) & time[6.20] > 15

The Annihilation cast actually has no criteria; it's a filler entry that spends the Demonsurge: Annihilation buff, so the Metamorphosis criteria are met above.

If initiative_tracker is the source of the previous issue, it will also solve for this item.

NOTE 2: I have also noticed that the addon struggles to manage the Fury and at some point, it forgets to recommend abilities like chaos blades, immolation aura, or sigil of flame even when they are off cd pastebin.com/TfDRWviq

• Chaos Blades is not an ability -- you have Demon Blades talented, so your Fury generation is conservatively predicted from auto-attacks. You can't use Chaos Strike.
• Immolation Aura is on cooldown for 9.7 seconds and is recommended in your queue as soon as it comes off CD.
• Sigil of Flame is off cooldown and has multiple entries that were ruled out:

• this entry's criteria FAILS: talent.student_of_suffering.enabled[true] & cooldown.eye_beam.remains[0.00] < gcd.max[1.00] & ( ! talent.inertia.enabled[true] | buff.inertia_trigger.up[false] ) & ( cooldown.essence_break.remains[0.00] < gcd.max[1.00] * 4 | ! talent.essence_break.enabled[true] ) & ( cooldown.metamorphosis.remains[27.27] > 10 | cooldown.blade_dance.remains[4.61] < gcd.max[1.00] * 3 ) & ( ! variable.trinket1_steroids[false] & ! variable.trinket2_steroids[false] | variable.trinket1_steroids[false] & ( trinket.t1.cooldown.remains[0.00] < gcd.max[1.00] * 3 | trinket.t1.cooldown.remains[0.00] > 20 ) | variable.trinket2_steroids[false] & ( trinket.t2.cooldown.remains[0.00] < gcd.max[1.00] * 3 | trinket.t2.cooldown.remains[0.00] > 20 ) )

This failed because buff.inertia_trigger.up is false, so I'll check that it's implemented correctly.

EDIT: another situation where I was struggling on Fury and the recommendations got stuck pastebin.com/P3LuSRqn pastebin.com/LUcTnZgY

What does "got stuck" mean? What are you expecting it to recommend differently, and why? It looks like these recommendations are mainly impacted by Eye Beam coming off CD in 15 seconds and having to conservatively estimate Fury gains from auto-attacks in the meantime.

NOTE 3: For this one I can't catch a snapshot for now because it's hard to reproduce, however sometimes the addon recommends vengeful retreat when Eye Beam is almost ready, making us lose the initiative proc. Secondly, it happened once that instead of waiting Essence Break to be off cd (2-3s left) the addon recommended using death sweep making us lose another dps proc

Will need snapshot(s).

EDIT: not the same thing, but the addon failed to pair vengeful retreat with meta here by recommending retreat randomly when meta was coming back in 8s pastebin.com/XN31VuKi

Would need to snapshot the Vengeful Retreat recommendation; it may be related to inertia_trigger or initiative_tracker above.

NOTE 4: Sometimes even if both EB and Death Sweep are up, the addon recommends to cast DS before EB. Also, there are still some issues sometimes where immo aura, sigil and blade dance don't get recommended even if they are off cd

Requires a snapshot.

@Hekili I will try to get snapshots where needed but as mentioned it's kinda random mid fight so I won't be quick enough to catch it. As for this

What does "got stuck" mean? What are you expecting it to recommend differently, and why? It looks like these recommendations are mainly impacted by Eye Beam coming off CD in 15 seconds and having to conservatively estimate Fury gains from auto-attacks in the meantime.

I expect the addon to recommend sigil and immo aura more often especially when we are running low fury. Instead, it is too conservative even if the spells will be available before either an eye beam combo or meta. Essentially it is too conservative because it starts around 10s before those 15s so you have around 5-6 seconds of auto attack only with the recommendations atm

Chaos Blades is not an ability -- you have Demon Blades talented, so your Fury generation is conservatively predicted from auto-attacks. You can't use Chaos Strike.

Misspelled Chaos Strike in "Chaos Blades" on my first message

Managed to get a snapshot of when I have sigil and immo aura available and low on fury but the system is too conservative (you could immo aura to get instant fury and feel rush later and still proc inertia): https://pastebin.com/1dck2MhH

Both the sim and the addon are using the same criteria; you can see that this entry would disappear if both Metamorphosis were active and your Fury reaches 40+. If Felblade vanishes under other circumstances, please provide a snapshot that shows this.

like this? https://justpaste.it.com/1ncsltaajt

I expect the addon to recommend sigil and immo aura more often especially when we are running low fury. Instead, it is too conservative even if the spells will be available before either an eye beam combo or meta. Essentially it is too conservative because it starts around 10s before those 15s so you have around 5-6 seconds of auto attack only with the recommendations atm

It looks like the sim is doing this as well; there is a 38 second gap between Immolation Auras starting at 2:18 unless I'm overlooking something. You may want to submit a SimC ticket with your Raidbots link. There's also a 4 second wait inside of that span where, you're right, Immolation Aura could've been used and generated some Fury.

I expect the addon to recommend sigil and immo aura more often especially when we are running low fury. Instead, it is too conservative even if the spells will be available before either an eye beam combo or meta. Essentially it is too conservative because it starts around 10s before those 15s so you have around 5-6 seconds of auto attack only with the recommendations atm

It looks like the sim is doing this as well; there is a 38 second gap between Immolation Auras starting at 2:18 unless I'm overlooking something. You may want to submit a SimC ticket with your Raidbots link. There's also a 4 second wait inside of that span where, you're right, Immolation Aura could've been used and generated some Fury.

Time # Name [List] Target Resources Buffs
2:18.799 b immolation_aura[meta] Yokaidh 170.0/170 100% fury metamorphosis, furious_gaze, tactical_retreat, demonsurge_sigil_of_doom, demonsurge_consuming_fire, demonsurge_abyssal_gaze, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(2), egg_sac(5), Ascendance_Haste(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_vers
2:19.871 c sigil_of_doom[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 170.0/170 100% fury immolation_aura, metamorphosis, furious_gaze, tactical_retreat, unbound_chaos, demonsurge_sigil_of_doom, demonsurge_abyssal_gaze, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(3), egg_sac(5), Ascendance_Haste(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_vers
2:20.941 f abyssal_gaze[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 170.0/170 100% fury immolation_aura, metamorphosis, furious_gaze, unbound_chaos, student_of_suffering, demonsurge_abyssal_gaze, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(4), egg_sac(5), Ascendance_Haste(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_vers
2:22.462 Z fel_rush[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 144.0/170 85% fury immolation_aura, metamorphosis, furious_gaze, inner_demon, unbound_chaos, student_of_suffering, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(5), Ascendance_Haste(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_vers
2:23.008 a essence_break[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 170.0/170 100% fury immolation_aura, metamorphosis, out_of_range, furious_gaze, inertia, inner_demon, student_of_suffering, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(5), Ascendance_Haste(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_vers
2:24.081 e death_sweep[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 170.0/170 100% fury immolation_aura, metamorphosis, furious_gaze, inertia, inner_demon, student_of_suffering, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(5), Ascension_Mastery(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_vers
2:25.180 g annihilation[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 170.0/170 100% fury immolation_aura, metamorphosis, furious_gaze, inertia, inner_demon, chaos_theory, student_of_suffering, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(6), Ascension_Mastery(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_vers
2:26.262 A pick_up_fragment[default] Fluffy_Pillow 154.0/170 91% fury immolation_aura, metamorphosis, furious_gaze, inertia, student_of_suffering, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(6), Ascension_Mastery(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_vers
2:26.283 g annihilation[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 154.0/170 91% fury immolation_aura, metamorphosis, furious_gaze, inertia, student_of_suffering, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(6), Ascension_Mastery(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_vers
2:27.384 g annihilation[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 170.0/170 100% fury immolation_aura, metamorphosis, furious_gaze, inertia, student_of_suffering, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(6), Ascension_Mastery(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:28.485 g annihilation[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 170.0/170 100% fury immolation_aura, metamorphosis, furious_gaze, student_of_suffering, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(6), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Mastery(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:29.585 g annihilation[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 139.0/170 82% fury metamorphosis, furious_gaze, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), spiderling, egg_sac(5), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Mastery(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:30.640 A pick_up_fragment[default] Fluffy_Pillow 151.0/170 89% fury metamorphosis, furious_gaze, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(5), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Mastery(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:30.687 F vengeful_retreat[default] Fluffy_Pillow 151.0/170 89% fury metamorphosis, furious_gaze, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(5), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Mastery(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:30.734 e death_sweep[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 151.0/170 89% fury metamorphosis, vengeful_retreat_movement, furious_gaze, initiative, tactical_retreat, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(5), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Mastery(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:31.836   Waiting 0.385s 144.0/170 85% fury metamorphosis, out_of_range, furious_gaze, initiative, tactical_retreat, chaos_theory, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(4), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Mastery(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:32.221 9 auto_attack[default] Fluffy_Pillow 144.0/170 85% fury metamorphosis, furious_gaze, initiative, tactical_retreat, chaos_theory, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(4), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:32.221 g annihilation[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 144.0/170 85% fury metamorphosis, furious_gaze, initiative, tactical_retreat, chaos_theory, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(4), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:33.322 g annihilation[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 149.0/170 88% fury metamorphosis, initiative, tactical_retreat, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, demonsurge(5), egg_sac(4), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:34.532 g annihilation[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 137.0/170 81% fury metamorphosis, initiative, tactical_retreat, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, egg_sac(4), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:35.743 g annihilation[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 161.0/170 95% fury metamorphosis, tactical_retreat, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, egg_sac(4), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:36.954 g annihilation[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 156.0/170 92% fury metamorphosis, tactical_retreat, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, egg_sac(4), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:38.165 e death_sweep[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 124.0/170 73% fury metamorphosis, tactical_retreat, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, spiderling, egg_sac(3), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:39.377 g annihilation[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 112.0/170 66% fury metamorphosis, tactical_retreat, chaos_theory, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, egg_sac(3), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:40.438 A pick_up_fragment[default] Fluffy_Pillow 100.0/170 59% fury metamorphosis, tactical_retreat, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, egg_sac(3), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:40.588 g annihilation[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 100.0/170 59% fury metamorphosis, tactical_retreat, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, egg_sac(3), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:41.695 A pick_up_fragment[default] Fluffy_Pillow 120.0/170 71% fury metamorphosis, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, egg_sac(3), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:41.798 g annihilation[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 120.0/170 71% fury metamorphosis, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, egg_sac(3), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:43.008 W annihilation[meta] Fluffy_Pillow 100.0/170 59% fury metamorphosis, demonsurge_demonic, demonsurge_hardcast, egg_sac(3), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:44.218 O felblade[default] Fluffy_Pillow 89.0/170 52% fury enduring_torment, monster_rising, egg_sac(3), Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:44.722 R chaos_strike[default] Fluffy_Pillow 129.0/170 76% fury enduring_torment, monster_rising, egg_sac(3), Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:46.106 N blade_dance[default] Fluffy_Pillow 104.0/170 61% fury enduring_torment, monster_rising, egg_sac(3), Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:47.490 R chaos_strike[default] Fluffy_Pillow 69.0/170 41% fury chaos_theory, enduring_torment, monster_rising, egg_sac(3), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascension_Crit(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:48.873 R chaos_strike[default] Fluffy_Pillow 60.0/170 35% fury enduring_torment, monster_rising, egg_sac(3), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascendance_Vers(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:50.256   Waiting 0.107s 20.0/170 12% fury enduring_torment, monster_rising, egg_sac(3), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascendance_Vers(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:50.363 R chaos_strike[default] Fluffy_Pillow 41.0/170 24% fury enduring_torment, monster_rising, egg_sac(3), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascendance_Vers(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:51.746   Waiting 4.268s 1.0/170 1% fury enduring_torment, monster_rising, egg_sac(3), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascendance_Vers(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery
2:56.014 J immolation_aura[default] Yokaidh 18.0/170 11% fury enduring_torment, monster_rising, egg_sac(3), authority_of_radiant_power, Ascendance_Vers(10), flask_of_alchemical_chaos_mastery

I sent the ticket to Raidbots with attached the screenshot of your previous message and the Sim I used to open this ticket. I will update you once I have a reply to the case

Closing due to age. I'll keep watching for sim updates.