Hello

On dreamgrove discord we was talking a bit about aoe prio for balance druid with Balance of All Things lego.
At this moment using hekili profile, hekili on 2+ targets with this lego, allways prio 1-2 Starsurge in first 1-2 sec after entering eclipse and if you miss it because you to slow, it will change for starfall. This profile have one problem, because if you use those 1-2 starsurge's you will always lose starfall uptime on 2+ targets, and having 100% uptime on SF on 2+ targets allways is prio ( if time to die is more than SF duration ) in m+ scenario this starsurge dumping is loss around 10-15% dps in overall.

Sec thing for enhancement is that, if you are in 3+ scenario and you are in lunar eclipse you never use moonfire's on 3+ targets, time when you refreshing moonfire dot is always in 3+ scenario solar eclipse. At 1-2 scenario, you want uptime moonfire/sunfire dots on any eclipse.

On ST hekili recommendation is almost 95% accurate , AP predictions are great and its working fine with Balance of all thing lego, but on AOE and m+ scenario, this tweak that always prio uptime starfall 100% on 2+ targets than use starsurge after entering eclipse will be nice dmg boost for those who using hekilii as rotation helper on m+

Sunfire dots refresh working great, because its prio for refreshing on any eclipse and any number of targets scenario.

If you want changes to recommendations, you need to post sims of the different behavior.

If you want changes to recommendations, you need to post sims of the different behavior.

its hard to get accurate sims for m+ scenario, recommendations that i posted above are after using and watching hekili over month on ST and AoE Scenarios and discussion with others bala druid's.

As bala druid with over 2k Rio i will add this tweek as great enhancement for m+ scenarios and recommendations.

You'd still need to provide the edits you've described and show how they sim.

Good catch and great research. The revised APLs are in a big pile of pending commits.

I would've accidentally resolved this with the next release, but it's good to have confirmation. I hope to get these changes out tonight or tomorrow. They require more checking than usual because of some recent syntax additions in SimC that I spotted and have to make sure are modeled correctly.

I am also seeing this, and I think I tracked down the APL cause. When I encountered it on a training dummy, I had no CDs up and paused to see what was up. Here was the state of the pause:

So, the issue is, look at the simc APL: https://github.com/simulationcraft/simc/blob/shadowlands/engine/class_modules/sc_druid.cpp#L8464
aoe->add_action( "starsurge,if=variable.dream_will_fall_off&variable.starfall_wont_fall_off&!variable.ignore_starsurge|(buff.balance_of_all_things_nature.stack>3|buff.balance_of_all_things_arcane.stack>3)&spell_targets.starfall<4&variable.starfall_wont_fall_off","Use Starsurge with Dreambinder to keep up the buff without losing Starfall uptime and use Starsurge on 4+ BoAT stacks until 4 targets" );

That last &variable.starfall_wont_fall_off is absent for hekili's APL, and without that we will use starsurge before we have starfall up incorrectly

Ah, was added in simulationcraft/simc@d722103

These fixes are in the new beta.