Pala Tank Preset , isnt Right . if you use it > You have no 8% Meelehit and 26 Expertise (Softcap)
And One Question , can you Add in the Future to Find The Right Gems and Enchants Combination to Reforge and Reach the Caps ? It Would Be Helping so much !
Thanks for your Time

I have found the issue at least for the Paladin, since I've seen others mention similar issues for other classes, mostly melee, as well.

Regarding Expertise Rating, the issue seems to be that the soft cap is at 421 instead of 481.

As for Hit Rating, there seems to be a double clause, first being no more than hit cap, and the second being no less than hit cap. This possibly messes the calculations unless you can reach that exact number via reforging your current equipment.

EDIT: All the above are true when you select Protection Paladin preset. If you change the value for Expertise Rating to manual (481) and remove the "At most" clause on Hit Rating, you will reach your desired caps.