Chisel

Chisel

150M Downloads

[1.12.2] Texture of Futura Blocks is messed up

Skaphegor opened this issue · 32 comments

commented

The texture is flickering. The gray and cyan variants are affected.

2017-12-28_11 05 19

commented

Optifine?

commented

Try without

commented

OptiFine 1.12.2 HD U C7

commented

Chisel - MC1.12-0.1.1.24
CTM - MC1.12-0.2.3.9
without Optifine
2017-12-30_01 38 47

commented

I have never seen this issue present without Optifine, and certainly can't reproduce it myself. Could you make a test world, and try removing mods? I can only assume this is some kind of bad interaction with another mod.

commented

I will check this.

commented

Hi, we're having the same z-fighting on our server. Here is our modlist with current versions: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XS4oFqjvtOMSajuKgJ6v1MvM3L1FD6YEaLbAYtJertg/edit?usp=sharing

2019-04-28_19 22 36

We don't use OptiFine, but we do have BetterFPS, as the other user mentioned. Tomorrow I'll do some testing.

commented

Okay! After roughly three hours of testing, I think the magic number is 188 mods (as listed by forge on the main Minecraft screen)/155 items in the mod folder. Adding even one mod to that causes the z-fighting. I have absolutely no idea why this would be the case, but it's the only conclusion I can draw from my testing.

I really hope this helps.

commented

Okay, well I just loaded an old save with 167 files in the mod folder and there's no z-fighting. So I have no idea. I give up, lol.

commented

Okay, sorry, I know I said I'd do testing a few days ago but I've finally gotten to it.

The first thing I noticed is that, even with all mods removed, the grey screen block is not animated. There's no z-fighting, but the animated texture only appears on the cyan. The grey block has a plain black screen. Not sure if that's intentional. Image of what I mean:

2019-05-03_07 59 09

After some testing, it seems that the z-fighting issue is tied to large modlists? Here is how I came to that conclusion:

  • I created a new modpack with the same version of MC (1.12.2) and Forge (forge-1.12.2-14.23.5.2825-universal) and Chisel (Chisel-MC1.12.2-0.2.1.35)/CTM (CTM-MC1.12.2-0.3.3.22) that I have on my main server.
  • In groups of ~5, I added in the mods from my modpack. The z-fighting did not occur until I reached Rustic.
  • I pulled all the mods out except Rustic, Chisel, and CTM - the z-fighting was gone. So I added back in a handful of mods at a time, tested them, then removed them and added in the next handful. Using this method, I worked my way through every mod in the folder without encountering the z-fighting.
  • At this point I was beginning to suspect that Rustic did not have anything to do with it, but rather that it was a numbers issue. I put all the mods I'd tested back in and encountered the z-fighting.
  • Then I removed Rustic and threw in another handful of mods. Lo and behold, the z-fighting returned. Removing them fixed the issue again.
  • I am now testing to see what the number of mods is that seems to be breaking the texture.
commented

Could you give me your modlist? I will check for same mods.

commented

Thanks for all your efforts. I have rustic in a few packs as well and this issue is still there as of the past update. Is rustic somehow the issue? The LE pack has only 126 mods so not sure if that is the z-fighting cause as its under 150. I will try to test again and post back. Here is the modlist of the LE pack on curse, https://minecraft.curseforge.com/projects/lighter-elements/relations/dependencies
Thanks.

commented

Chasing mod counts is a red herring. It's either one specific mod causing it, or it's not related to mods at all. A more productive line of questioning might be to say what GPU you have (check F3 screen). If everyone affected is on one type of card (Intel/AMD/Nvidia) it's probably a hardware issue.

commented
commented

As you all can see, I have 940M in the screenshots,
I will check if it happens with GTX 650 now.

commented

Accidentally, I removed Tinkers' Compendium, formerly known as Tinkers' Defense. Issue seems to be fixed now.

2019-05-22_13 59 59

commented

Seems broken on GTX 650 also. Here is a list of mods if anyone might see any similaritie.
mods.txt

2019-05-22_10 21 33

commented

I have a gtx980 if that helps, so is it driver related then on how its rendered?

commented

@tterrag1098 I made a test. I placed all blocks without Tinkers' Compendium again. I had no bugs. Then I added it back. The bug returned.

2019-05-24_03 15 06
2019-05-24_03 42 29

commented

I have no idea if it's hardware related, but that seems unlikely as I dev and test on a GTX770. I doubt Tinkers' Compendium is at fault, unless adding it back reliably triggers the issue again?

commented

I do not have Tinker's Compendium in my modlist, so I'm not sure it's that. I'm sorry this isn't better formatted, but my current modlist is here.

commented

@katubug You can place this if saved as .bat in your mod folder and run then. It will print out a .txt file with contents of the folder in which it has been placed. You will need to edit a bit, but it will be formatted well.

commented

After I joined the test world again for some work with CraftTweaker, the futura blocks were broken although I did not change any mod. This means the bug is still sporadically.

commented

Here is a link to my full modlist:

mods.txt

commented

We are getting this on 1.12.2 with the grey screen texture futura block. We are using Chisel mod version 1.12.2-0.2.0.31/CTM-1.12.2-0.3.0.15, Forge-14.23.4.2705, in a custom mod-pack on curse. The blue screen ones work fine. Does the Better-FPS mod interfere with this texture? Not using optifine. Thanks
https://minecraft.curseforge.com/projects/lighter-elements/relations/dependencies
is a link to the mod dependencies that are in the pack.

image
image

commented

2019-07-23_21 56 24
z fighting problems in enigmatica 2 1.68a
modlist:
modlist.txt
i tried removing betterfps,foamfix and disable forge's threaded chunk loading but problem still persists
i am also using intel's integrated graphics(hd 4600)

commented

Through a lengthy process of trial and error, I discovered that less lag was causing the problem. I removed that, and it worked.

commented

Old bug report but while this issue didn't show up with StoneBlock 2 I'm noticing it with FTB Revelations. The key part is that Tinker's Compendium (or Tinker's Defense) is not present in this specific pack.

commented

Also having the same issue all of a sudden, I have no idea what's causing it.

commented

This issue appears and reappears again and again, without changing any mods. Also, this bug tends to disappear. Thus, I do doubt that it is related to another mod.
It is more likely a strange interaction between vanilla minecraft, forge or graphic drivers.

commented

Do we have now a fix for that ?