Description

For some reason, custom sounds cannot be played.
I made a simple avatar (attached to this issue) to test to play custom sound, but I could not play it.
@GNanimates GNamimates#2357 helped me to solve this issue but I could not solve the probrem in the end. Please see the #Rewrite Hellp Thread in Figura discord server for conversation at that time.

How to reproduce

1. Use the avatar attached this issue.
2. Playes a custom sound with a vanilla sound if custom sound works currectly.

At least, I could not play it.

Note

• I give my self a permission to play custom sound.
• Sound from Otojin.

Attachments

• test.zip

Ogg has a lot of different codecs, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ogg#Ogg_codecs
This issue is related to Minecraft using the codec "vorbis", while the attached sound uses a different, unsupported, codec

Seems like I was wrong and misjudged the issue too quickly
Since the sounds plays whitin resource packs just fine, that is considered a Figura bug

Is it possible for figura to give you an error if you use the wrong codec? Probably would help others dealing with this issue.

Maybe as an extra thing, lead it to a command that gives you more info on how to get an ogg file with the right codec.

that would fall into the (planned) wiki page for custom sounds

unfortunately nope, as the sound loading is done internally in the minecraft code

the real issue is that the sounds actually load, however in game they appear completely muted

What about the second half of our comment?

ok the issue has been fixed now and gonna be present on the next build