Sodium

Sodium

44M Downloads

Sodium changes fluid rendering compared to vanilla

coderbot16 opened this issue · 13 comments

commented

A water flow rendered by the current Sodium next branch:

2021-03-26_23.56.16.png

The same water flow, rendered in vanilla:

2021-03-26_23.59.03.png

I'm not sure if this is intended behavior or not.

commented

I made a PR to fix this issue with #2467. Does it work as expected?

commented

yes it does.

commented

This issue is still valid in 0.4.10. The difference is really hard to see though.

commented

this is a duplicate of #38, it’s a translucency sorting issue. the fix is non-trivial, but the dev team is working on it.

commented

I've got similar issues with my water as well. However, I've got an issue where water makes ice transparent for whatever reason.

2023-06-21_16 41 04
2023-06-21_16 40 54
2023-06-21_16 40 17

commented

The original report is not #38, but the followup images are.

commented

As coderbot mentioned, the orientation of the crease is changed. I've discovered that the orientation of the crease is differs between the inside-facing and outside-facing quad of such a piece of water. I've attached two screenshots from within and outside of water with the crease highlighted.
2023-10-10_01 19 49
2023-10-10_01 20 03

commented

Not sure if this is the correct place to post this, but I have had some other weird issues with water that seem similar to what your are having:
2021-05-20_16 06 17
2021-05-20_16 05 34
2021-05-20_16 05 43
2021-05-20_16 05 52
2021-05-20_16 06 00

commented

@mscatloaf The problem you are showing here is #38. This issue is about the particular shape of the water flow, not the translucency problems when they overlap.

commented

This is #38 - lack of translucency sorting - right?

commented

That's what I originally thought, however if you look closely at the top of the water flow, you can see that the geometry of the diagonal faces is quite different (a flat face instead of a "V" face). It seems like this is separate from the previous translucency sorting issues.

commented

It's possible that this is actually related to the fact that vanilla is generating degenerate non-coplanar quads here, and since Sodium changes the orientation of vertices in quads due to lighting, it might be changing the appearance of the quads too.

commented

A non-coplanar quad will render differently depending on how it is converted to triangles, and changing the orientation of the vertices changes how it is converted to triangles:

ridge_valley.gif