VanillaTweaks [Fabric & Forge]

VanillaTweaks [Fabric & Forge]

8M Downloads

[1.16] Hops enchantment cancels/reduces the momentum of the player when jumping

Duxtorm opened this issue · 4 comments

commented

Uh... hello, me again x-x; (I'm sorry)

I've spent a good portion of 3 hours doing experiments back and forth between the effects of the Hops Enchantment and the Jump Boost effect.. eventually I was able to create a scenario which clearly demonstrated the difference between the two.

If I give myself speed effect 12 ( XII + I ), I'm able to make a 7-block jump easily enough.
If I then give myself jump boost 0 ( I ) on top of the speed effect, I'm able to make the jump easier.. each time I increase the level of the jump boost effect, the jump gets easier and I'm able to make it further and further across, however-
If I instead use boots with the Hops enchant 1-3 (still with speed 12), it hinders my ability to make the jump, often losing all my momentum and falling to the ground only 4-5 blocks from where I jumped.

Immediately after my first time trying hops + nimble, I found that every time I jumped, my momentum would deplete immediately.
Continuously jumping would make me travel at a normal, unaffected pace as I jumped, regardless of any speed buff.

Jump boost on the other hand, preserves much of your momentum, giving you smoother, more effective jumps.

From all this, my only conclusion is, I feel the Hops enchantment would be much more appealing if it didn't halt your momentum when you jump, and I feel that it actually hinders your over-all ability to travel.

  • Forge Version: 36.2.4
  • MC Version: 1.16.5
  • Mod Version: 1.5.42
  • JEI Version (if present) : 7.7.1.121
  • Baubles Version (if present) : n/a
  • Curios Version (if present) : n/a

Side note: (Unrelated and unimportant)
I've also found that there is absolutely no difference between the effects of the Nimble enchant and the Speed effect XD

[Sprinting]

None - 100 Blocks | 17.80 Sec (≈ 5.62 Blx/s)

Nimble I - 100 Blocks | 14.80 Sec (≈ 6.75 Blx/s)
Nimble II - 100 Blocks | 12.70 Sec (≈ 7.87 Blx/s)
Nimble III - 100 Blocks | 11.20 Sec (≈ 8.93 Blx/s)

Speed I - 100 Blocks | 14.80 Sec (≈ 6.75 Blx/s)
Speed II - 100 Blocks | 12.70 Sec (≈ 7.87 Blx/s)
Speed III - 100 Blocks | 11.20 Sec (≈ 8.93 Blx/s)

--

[Jump Height]

None - 1.25

Hops I - 2.250 Blocks
Hops II - 2.875 Blocks
Hops III - 3.625 Blocks

Jump Boost I - 1.750 Blocks
Jump Boost II - 2.500 Blocks
Jump Boost III - 3.250 Blocks

commented

lHops is implement such that it adds jump boost whereas nimble uses the entity attributes. Maybe thats causing the issue?

I am not sure i understand the problem fully Can you contact me via discord for further contact and some clarification.

commented

Sure! Though, how do I find your Discord?
Mine's Mishka#6236

commented

Fixed the issue and uploaded an new version on curseforge.