Chisels & Bits - For Forge

Chisels & Bits - For Forge

108M Downloads

Chisel modes don't work in Creative Mode

DrGamble opened this issue ยท 13 comments

commented

I have encountered an issue with the ChiselsAndBits Mod.
Some modes won't work if you play on creative mode when using a new chisel.
I have installed the mod using the forge installer and the standard client drag/drop method.
I have run this in an isolated instance of Minecraft 1.19.2 to see if it is potentially due to cross-mod incompatibility, but the bug remains.

Issue Information

To Reproduce:

  1. Play on Creative
  2. Acquire a new chisel of any type
  3. Try to use on any block with any of the affected modes listed below

workaround:

  1. Play on any game mode
  2. Acquire a new chisel of any type
  3. Switch to Survival (if not already on it)
  4. Use once on any chisel mode to apply the item durability bar to chisel
  5. Switch to Creative
  6. Use the chisel

Affected Modes:

  • Extrude

    • all modes work
    • gives a message "The state you are trying to place is not valid."
  • Connected Plane

    • all modes work
    • gives a message "The state you are trying to place is not valid."
  • Plane

    • all modes work
    • gives a message "The state you are trying to place is not valid."
  • Drawn Cube

    • no modes work
    • no message was given
  • Line

    • no modes work
    • no message was given

Mod and Minecraft information:

  • Minecraft version: 1.19.2
  • Forge? Yes
    • Forge Version 43.2.8
    • Scena 1.0.93
  • Optifine? No
  • ChiselsAndBits version: 1.3.129

Additional references:

Related issues:

  • #1086
    • Closed by the poster
    • The issue was not resolved
  • #931
    • Closed by the dev
    • Stated it was fixed in ChiselsAndBits v1.2.100
commented

Having the same sort of issues. Tried the work work around suggested of going to survival, using a chisel, and then returning to creative. Now the line mode works, which it wasn't before, but everything is a bit off from where it should be, the bits come out a few bits down. Haven't tried starting Minecraft with only Chisels & Bits loaded, I'll have a go at this tomorrow.

commented

Did you install the mod with the curse forge launcher?

commented

No, I installed it by dropping the jar into the mods folder that's created after installing forge

commented

Then I will need the debug.log file to check what is going on.

commented
commented

Okey. From your log it is indicated that there are some other mods loaded. Can you check if this happens with just c and b?

commented

debug.log
Okay, I created a new installation with just the C&B mod, but the issue remains.

commented

How do you install forge?

commented

Specifically thru the site's downloadable installer.

commented

Sorry but I can not reproduce this.
If I install those exact versions it works for me without a hitch.
There must be something in your system that prevents it from working.

commented

I also experience this issue despite under different versions, with Minecraft version 1.20.1, Forge version 47.1.44, C&B version 1.4.141, and JEI version 15.2.0.25. No other mods are installed.

commented

By the way, what does "extrude" chisel mode actually do? It seems not working properly for me. (It acts exactly like "plane" mode) Any footage please? Thanks in advance.